This isn’t strictly a wish list–it is also an attempt for me to catalog the My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic toys. The toys that I own are listed, the toys that I don’t own are in pink. Ponies or sets that I want most are bold. Ponies that I have purchased (or attempted to purchase) but have not yet arrived are starred*.
LAST UPDATED: Tuesday, March 24, 2015
2010 Single Release Ponies
♥ APPLEJACK with dog
♥ FLUTTERSHY with bunny
♥ PINKIE PIE with mouse
♥ TWILIGHT SPARKLE with owl
♥ RAINBOW DASH with squirrel
♥ RARITY with bird
2010 Special Single Release Ponies
♥ Spring FLUTTERSHY
♥ Valentine PINKIE PIE
2010 – 2011 Shine Bright Ponies
♥ SHINE BRIGHT PINKIE PIE
♥ SHINE BRIGHT RAINBOW DASH
♥ SHINE BRIGHT RARITY
2010 – 2015 Fashion Style Ponies
♥ FASHION STYLE APPLEJACK
♥ FASHION STYLE PINKIE PIE
♥ FASHION STYLE RARITY
♥ FASHION STYLE FLUTTERSHY
♥ FASHION STYLE RAINBOW DASH
♥ FASHION STYLE TWILIGHT SPARKLE
♥ FASHION STYLE PRINCESS CELESTIA
♥ FASHION STYLE PRINCESS LUNA
♥ FASHION STYLE PRINCESS TWILIGHT SPARKLE
♡ FASHION STYLE PRINCESS CADENCE
♡ FASHION STYLE CRYSTAL EMPIRE PINKIE PIE
♥ Rainbow Power FASHION STYLE RARITY
♡ Rainbow Power FASHION STYLE PINKIE PIE
♡ Rainbow Power FASHION STYLE RAINBOW DASH
♡ Rainbow Power FASHION STYLE APPLEJACK
♡ Rainbow Power FASHION STYLE DAISY DREAMS
♡ Cutie Mark Magic FASHION STYLE PRINCESS CADENCE
♡ Cutie Mark Magic FASHION STYLE SUNSET SHIMMER
♥ Rainbow Power FASHION STYLE PRINCESS TWILIGHT SPARKLE (Kohl’s)
♡ Rainbow Power RAINBOW PRINCESS TWILIGHT SPARKLE
♡ Rainbow Power PRINCESS TWILIGHT SPARKLE & PRINCESS CELESTIA
2010 – 2011 Playsets
♥ APPLEJACK’S SWEET APPLE BARN Playset
♥ FLUTTERSHY’S NURSERY TREE Playset
♥ PINKIE PIE AND SWEETIE BELLE’S SWEETS BOUTIQUE Playset
♥ RARITY’S ROYAL GEM CARRIAGE Playset
♥ TWILIGHT SPARKLE’S TWINKLING BALLOON Playset
♥ FRIENDSHIP IS MAGIC Gift Set
♡ PINKIE PIE’S RC Car
♥ RAINBOW DASH’S CAMPING TRIP Playset
♥ APPLEJACK’S FARM TRUCK
♡ PONYVILLE SCHOOLHOUSE Playset
♡ FUN AT THE FAIR WITH APPLE BLOOM & SWEETIE BELLE Playset
♥ RARITY’S CAROUSEL BOUTIQUE Playset
♡ AFTERNOON PICNIC WITH CHEERILEE
♥ PONY SCHOOL PALS AND CHEERILEE
♡ SWEET SLUMBERS WITH APPLEJACK & STAR DREAMS
♥ ROYAL CASTLE FRIENDS WITH PRINCESS CELESTIA, TWILIGHT SPARKLE & SPIKE
Friendship Express Train
♥ FRIENDSHIP EXPRESS TRAIN
♡ FLUTTERSHY’S NURSERY TRAIN CAR
♡ SWEETIE BELL’S ICE CREAM TRAIN CAR
2010 – 2012 Bonus Ponies
♥ DAISY DREAMS with butterfly (with FLUTTERSHY with bunny)
♥ RAINBOW FLASH with turtle (with RAINBOW DASH with squirrel)
♥ STAR SWIRL (with RARITY’S ROYAL GEM CARRIAGE Playset)
♥ SKYWISHES (with RIDING ALONG WITH RAINBOW DASH SKATEBOARD)
2011 Single Release Ponies
♥ CHEERILEE with turtle
♥ LILY BLOSSOM with swan
♥ BLOSSOMFORTH with hedgehog
♥ CUPCAKE with raccoon
♥ DEWDROP DAZZLE with duck
♥ LULU LUCK with chipmunks
♥ FEATHERMAY with parrot
♥ FLITTERHEART with pig
♥ HONEYBUZZ with bee
♥ PLUMSWEET with hamster
♥ SNOWCATCHER with cat
♥ TWINKLESHINE with koala
2011 Riding Along Ponies
♥ RIDING ALONG WITH FLUTTERSHY TRICYCLE
♥ RIDING ALONG WITH RAINBOW DASH SKATEBOARD
♥ RIDING ALONG WITH TWILIGHT SPARKLE SCOOTER
2011 Canterlot Target
♥ SHINE BRIGHT FLUTTERSHY
♥ SHINE BRIGHT PINKIE PIE
♥ FASHION STYLE PRINCESS LUNA & PRINCESS CELESTIA
♥ PRINCESS CELESTIA & PRINCESS LUNA
♥ CELEBRATION at CANTERLOT CASTLE with SHINE BRIGHT TWILIGHT SPARKLE & STARBEAM TWINKLE
♥ CANTERLOT CASTLE with SHINE BRIGHT PRINCESS LUNA & PINKIE PIE
♥ ROYAL BALL at CANTERLOT CASTLE with APPLEJACK, FLUTTERSHY, PINKIE PIE, RAINBOW DASH, RARITY, & TWILIGHT SPARKLE
Glimmer Wings Ponies
♥ GLIMMER WINGS RAINBOW DASH
♥ GLIMMER WINGS RARITY
♥ GLIMMER WINGS PLOOMETTE
♥ GLIMMER WINGS FLUTTERSHY
♥ GLIMMER WINGS DAISY DREAMS
2012 Single Release Ponies
♥ APPLEJACK with ladybug and suitcase
♥ FLUTTERSHY with chipmunks and suitcase
♥ PINKIE PIE with hedgehog and suitcase
♥ RAINBOW DASH with duck and suitcase
♥ RARITY with butterfly and suitcase
♥ TWILIGHT SPARKLE with dog and suitcase
♥ CHERRY PIE with mouse and suitcase
♥ DIAMOND ROSE with swan and suitcase
Canterlot Wedding Single Release Ponies
♡ APPLEJACK with punch bowl and invitation
♡ FLUTTERSHY with gift box and invitation
♥ PINKIE PIE with cake and invitation
♡ RAINBOW DASH with picture frame and invitation
♡ RARITY with purse and invitation
♥ TWILIGHT SPARKLE with flower arrangement and invitation
♥ CHERRY BERRY with cake and invitation
♥ LYRA HEARTSTRINGS with picture frame and invitation
♥ SUNNY RAYS with punch bowl and invitation
♥ TRIXIE LULAMOON with gift box and invitation
Canterlot Wedding Bridle Friends
♥ Bridle Friends FLUTTERSHY
♥ Bridle Friends PINKIE PIE
♥ Bridle Friends RARITY
♥ Bridle Friends TWILIGHT SPARKLE
Canterlot Wedding Playsets
♥ Wedding Flower Fillies Set
♥ Princess Wedding Castle Playset
♥ Princess Wedding Princess Cadence
♡ TWILIGHT SPARKLE & PRINCESS CADANCE Crystal Jewel Salon
♡ PINKIE PIE & FLUTTERSHY Crystal Sparkle Bath
♡ TWILIGHT SPARKLE’s Wedding RC Car
2012 Crystal Empire Target
♥ Glimmer Wings DIAMOND ROSE & PINKIE PIE (Target)
♥ Glimmer Wings SWEET SONG & FLUTTERSHY (Target)
♥ Fashion Style PRINCESS CADENCE & SHINING ARMOR (Target)
♥ Crystal Princess Ponies Collection (Target)
2012 Pony Friends Forever Toys ‘R Us
♥ RIDING ALONG WITH RARITY and DAISY DREAMS (Toys ‘R Us)
♥ PRINCESS CELESTIA & FRIENDS Teatime (Toys ‘R Us)
2012 Collector Series Toys ‘R Us
♥ Favourite Collection Set (Toys ‘R Us)
♥ ZECORA (Toys ‘R Us)
♥ PRINCESS CELESTIA (Toys ‘R Us)
2013 Crystal Empire Single Release Playful Ponies
♥ APPLEJACK
♡ FLUTTERSHY
♥ PINKIE PIE
♡ RAINBOW DASH
♥ RARITY
♥ TWILIGHT SPARKLE
2013 Crystal Empire Crystal Motion Ponies
♥ APPLEJACK with puppy
♥ RAINBOW DASH with turtle
♥ TWILIGHT SPARKLE with bird
♡ FLUTTERSHY with butterfly comb
♡ PINKIE PIE with heart comb
♡ RARITY with gem comb
2013 Crystal Empire Princess & Friend
♥ PRINCESS CELESTIA & PINKIE PIE
♥ PRINCESS LUNA & RARITY
♡ PRINCESS CADENCE & Applejack
♡ PRINCESS TWILIGHT SPARKLE & Rainbow Dash
2013 Crystal Empire
♡ Promo Pack with TWILIGHT SPARKLE and PLOOMETTE
2013 Crystal Princess Masquerade Singles
♥ PINKIE PIE
♥ RAINBOW DASH
♥ RARITY
♥ SUNSET SHIMMER
♡ APPLEJACK
♡ FLUTTERSHY
Vehicle Playsets
♡ PRINCESS CELEBRATION CAR
♡ PINKIE PIE’s Rainbow Helicopter
♡ PRINCESS TWILIGHT SPARKLE’s Charm Carriage
♡ FLUTTERSHY & Scooter
Building Playsets
♡ FRIENDSHIP RAINBOW KINGDOM
♡ CANTERLOT CASTLE
♥ Rainbow Power RAINBOW DASH & RARITY Spa Pony Set (Kohl’s)
2013 Rainbow Power Fantastic Flutter Ponies
♡ PRINCESS CADENCE
♡ PRINCESS TWILIGHT SPARKLE
2013 Pony Packs
♡ MIDNIGHT IN CANTERLOT Minty Collection (Costco)
♡ CUTIE MARK CRUSADERS & Friends Collection
2014 Rainbow Power Playful Ponies Singles
♡ APPLEJACK
♥ FLUTTERSHY
♥ PINKIE PIE
♡ RAINBOW DASH
♡ RARITY
♡ TWILIGHT SPARKLE
2014 Rainbow Power Full Body Symbol Singles
♡ CHEERILEE
♡ FLUTTERSHY
♡ HOLLY DASH
♡ PINKIE PIE
♡ RAINBOW DASH
♡ RARITY
2014 Rainbow Power Rainbow Shimmer Ponies
♥ PRINCESS CELESTIA
♡ PRINCESS CADENCE
♥ PRINCESS LUNA
♡ PRINCESS TWILIGHT SPARKLE
2015 Cutie Mark Magic Water Cuties Ponies
♡ DIAMOND MINT
♡ PINKIE PIE
♥ RARITY
2014 – 2015 Cutie Mark Magic Full Body Symbol Singles
♡ APPLEJACK
♡ FLOWER WISHES
♡ FLUTTERSHY
♡ PINKIE PIE
♡ PRINCESS TWILIGHT SPARKLE
♡ RAINBOW DASH
♡ RARITY
♡ SKYWISHES
♡ SUNSET SHIMMER
♡ SWEETIE DROPS
2014 Bagged Singles
♡ APPLEJACK
♡ CHEERILEE
♡ FLUTTERSHY
♡ LILY BLOSSOM
♡ LYRA HEARTSTRINGS
♡ PINKIE PIE
♡ RAINBOW DASH
♡ RARITY
♡ CHEERILEE
2014 – 2015 Rainbow Power/Cutie Mark Magic Breezie Friends
♥ FLUTTERSHY & Sea Breezie
♥ PRINCESS TWILIGHT SPARKLE & Sunset Breezie
2014 – 2015 Rainbow Power/Cutie Mark Magic Princess & Friend
♡ PRINCESS STERLING & Fluttershy
♡ PRINCESS GOLD LILY & Pinkie Pie
2014 – 2015 Rainbow Power/Cutie Mark Magic Styling Strands Ponies
♡ FLUTTERSHY
♡ RARITY
2015 Cutie Mark Magic Charm Wings Ponies
♡ FLUTTERSHY
♡ HONEY RAYS
♡ RAINBOW DASH
2015 Cutie Mark Magic Glamour Glow Ponies
♡ PRINCESS CADENCE
♡ RARITY
Event and Store Exclusive Ponies
♡ Comic Con & MLP Fair Exclusive 2012 (Derpy Hooves)
♡ Comic Con & MLP Fair Exclusive 2013 (DJ PON-3)
♡ Comic Con & MLP Fair Exclusive 2014 (MANE-IAC MAYHEM)
♡ PRINCESS TWILIGHT SPARKLE (Hasbro Toy Shop)
♡ Chinese New Year PINKIE PIE (Toys ‘R Us)
♥ NURSE REDHEART (Walgreens)
Wave 1 Blind Bag Ponies
♥ PINKIE PIE #1
♥ RARITY #4
♥ MINTY #9
♥ glittery/transparent pink PINKIE PIE #22
♥ glittery/transparent purple TWILIGHT SPARKLE #23
♥ glittery/transparent blue RAINBOW DASH #24
Wave 4 Blind Bag Ponies
♥ crystal orange APPLEJACK #1
♥ crystal yellow FLUTTERSHY #2
♥ crystal ROYAL RIFF #6
♥ crystal CHANCE-A-LOT #10
♥ metallic silvery RARITY #12
♥ crystal white RARITY #14
♥ crystal TWILIGHT SKY #17
♥ metallic gold APPLEJACK #18
♥ metallic pink PINKIE PIE #24
Friendship is Magic Keychains
♥ transparent pink PINKIE PIE
♥ transparent blue RAINBOW DASH
Friendship is Magic 2011 Happy Meal Toys
♥ APPLEJACK
♥ FLUTTERSHY
♥ PINKIE PIE
♥ RAINBOW DASH
♥ RARITY
♥ TWILIGHT SPARKLE
Friendship is Magic 2012 Happy Meal Toys
♥ PINKIE PIE